So was I, but as a lifelong New Yorker I can't deny the regression happening in front of my eyes: the recent huge waves of migration from gay-hostile countries to NYC have almost wiped out many of the coalitions and population that was supportive or at least tolerant of gays. It is easy to get fooled by the seeming "freedom" in parts of glamorous Manhattan, but if you venture too far uptown or wander naively thru the other boroughs, you can get in serious trouble if you don't watch your back.
Aside from isolated pockets of hipsters in places like Williamsburg, Brooklyn is not gay-friendly (and some neighborhoods you would think are cool are actually incredibly dangerous). Queens has lost nearly its entire population of native-New-Yorker liberals in the past decade: they have been replaced by insular cultures who prefer to act as if they are still back home. There's a lot of infighting and tribalism between them, but one thing they all agree on is hostility toward gays. As they become more involved in the political system, they pose increasingly grave threats to gay safety.
Today it's almost post gay. Almost. [...] Here in Boston, we no longer have gay neighborhoods, because we live everywhere. Gay bars, gay businesses? A few. It's just not a thing anymore.
That right there is part of the problem, causing this current "one step forward, two steps back" phenomenon. For better and worse, the "gay ghetto" neighborhoods of the past made us highly visible and concentrated. It was easier to draw attention from the media when necessary, organize politically, etc. Today, with us dispersed, less attention is paid to crimes against us, punishment for perpetrators has lessened or disappeared, and gay-hostile groups are emboldened because we have no obvious day-to-presence anymore. Our current (and likely to be re-elected) mayor is an ineffective, disorganized, arrogant, hypocritical nitwit who constantly makes matters worse.
So we're getting attacked frequently, more randomly dispersed, more isolated from fellow gays. And those who work against us politically are gaining surprising influence. As the saying goes, "sometimes you're not being paranoid- they really are out to get you". Its nice to think its 2016 and we can relax, but that would be self-deception: the price of freedom is constant vigilance.
I'm very optimistic about gay rights in America. I've seen the arc over time.
So am I, so have I. But we must not mistake over-hyped Pyrrhic victories like the marriage issue for large-scale acceptance or completed progress. There is still a long way to go at the very local level where we all actually live out our lives. I've been to Boston, had relatives living there: its a lovely city. Quite possibly it has been spared some of the regressive changes wracking New York and other gay meccas (despite their supposedly liberal politics). I certainly hope your personal experience of it reflects the broader picture in Massachusetts.
Its only a matter of time before we all become fully integrated and gay vs straight becomes a complete non-issue, or even a humorous historical footnote in America. But our population has radically shifted in the past fifteen years, stalling progress and requiring us to start all over again in some respects. Every inch of ground we gain can shift at any moment due to factors beyond our control or expectation. As long as we don't get complacent, we'll keep gaining.