Well, I tried it for the first time last night and it didn't come out as great as I was hoping for. After I mixed the flour, yeast, sugar, salt, and oil and was starting to kneed it, it wasn't as soft and sticky as I've seen on TV or even my grandmother make. It was tough, and dry, and it didn't rise very much. After I baked it, it seemed a little raw in the center.
I'm thinking that I either used too much flour or not enough water. The recipe called for 3 1/2 cups of flour to 1 cup of warm water. I was thinking about cutting back to 3 cups of flour on the next attempt and see what happens.
If anyone has suggestions, I'd be listening
Well, from what you described, you added a little too much flour. Typically you have added enough flour when the dough starts to pull away from the sides and form a ball - it will still be sticky though - this is the time to add flour only a Tbsp or two at a time - just to be able to knead the dough (usually 5-10 min. if you are doing it by hand). Most bread recipes are just rough estimates for flour, it depends on temp, humidity and the type of flour you use - as your grandmother might say, you have to "develop a feel" for the dough!
I usually proof my yeast before adding it to the flour, warm water, 1 tsp sugar and yeast, stir and let sit for 5-10 min - it should be all boubly, if your yeast is good and active. If your water is too hot, it will kill the yeast!
Most recipes don't say this, but salt retards the yeast proofing process, so I typically don't add my salt until I am in the kneading phase. Just mix it with a Tbsp of flour and knead it in well.
The other thing you might want to invest in is good food thermometer, I have never been able to determine if my loaves were done by the tapping for the hollow sound method. I usually just make sure my loaves reach an internal temp. of 190 and that should fix your raw center issue.
Hope this helps! If you have more questions, please let me know! Don't give up - you can do this!!!