Like most American boys, I had seen a couple of Playboys that my friend's fathers had hidden away now and then. But when the pics didn't give me the huge thrill the same way my pals reacted, I just chalked it up to them being weird and didn't give it a second thought.
Later, my "gay porn" history kicked off in such an odd manner, nobody believes me when I tell them. Back when I was around 12 y/o, I accompanied my mother on a grocery shopping trip. She was in one of her eccentric cranky moods, and impulsively told me "just stay in the car". She walked over to the candy/magazine store that was near the grocery market, and returned a short time later. Instead of getting in, she pulled a magazine out of a brown bag and shoved it in my face thru the car window, saying "here, read this, maybe you'll learn something while I finish shopping".
After she stalked off, I realized the magazine she handed me was "Playgirl" and it was full of naked men! My eyes went wide, my tongue dried up, and I was instantly hooked. The centerfold was then-TV-star Gary Conway, and the travel feature had a tall, lanky, long-haired dude swimming in Cozumel Mexico. He was handsome, hairy-chested, hung to his knees, and his face just radiated confident, easy, sensual masculinity while he held the female co-model in his arms. To this day I've never seen another male face that sensual: I didn't really know what sex was all about yet, but his face seemed to promise something wonderful and secret and a little scary. That day was my first conscious inkling that "hmmm, there's something different about me..."
I still have that magazine (I grabbed it from the trash when she threw it away), but I've never known what my mother was thinking when she insisted I read that Playgirl. We never discussed it, indeed I've never officially come out to her or my father. Everyone else in my family knows, and my parents have met and befriended several of my partners over the years, but we simply never discuss my orientation: we embarked on a "don't ask, don't tell" policy long before the military. If we ever did discuss it, I'm sure she's long forgotten the "Playgirl" incident, which is too bad: I would love to jokingly tell her SHE "made me gay" by that gesture in 1973 Brooklyn.
Anyway, after my first taste, I would turn the house upside down hoping to find similar magazines whenever my parents left on errands. Eventually I discovered my mother bought Playgirl every month, and had a stash hidden in the hall closet (closet-ha ha). For the next year and a half, I had something to look forward to every month, and then she stopped buying it. By then, I was nearly fourteen, looked seventeen, but was still as sexually clueless as when I was twelve: the pics of naked guys got me all worked up, but I truly had no idea why. Until one day, a bodega run by Arabs opened up in my neighborhood, and I noticed they had magazines called Mandate and Honcho. I brazenly tried to buy one along with the newspapers, and they let me!
After that, I amassed quite the collection of Honcho and Mandate, because that was as close to gay porn as a teen could get in the mid-1970s. Its funny to remember that time, because in some minor respects it was much "freer" than it is today. It never occurred to parents or anyone to boycott stores for carrying gay rags like Honcho, Mandate or Advocate Men- even if they were down the street from a church in my Catholic Brooklyn neighborhood. I couldn't imagine anyone besides me was buying those magazines, and I guess thats how they slipped by: if you weren't interested, you probably wouldn't notice them on the rack at all.
Another couple years went by, and I *still* didn't have a clear notion of why I was attracted to men or what they did sexually (the gay mags were all solo pictorials, and the fiction seemed surreal). Finally, I got a job working in an early video store, and they had a small handful of gay porn tapes mixed in with the straight stuff. I waited until I was the only clerk on duty one day, and slipped "Al Parker: Inches" into the store VCR. Suffice to say, that was a fairly comprehensive lesson in what my attraction meant and what men did with that attraction. A couple years later, when Al Parker adopted his long-haired "Hot Gay Jesus" look, it permanently clarified exactly what type of guy turned me on the most.
***********
UPDATE: several of you have contacted me to ask for a pic of the infamous magazine. Unfortunately not much of it is available in web archives, as it is very old now (August 1973), but I did find the front cover and another page, both featuring the man from the Cozumel pictorial. :cheers: