For me this subject is trickier then it seems in first sight. Half a year ago I did a lot of work on an Asian video with a young lad in it. After hours and hours of work I felt suddenly uncomfortable and threw the whole bunch away. First I did not understand why I had that strange feeling. The boy looked very young, in my opinion hardly sixteen, but as mentioned above, the boys in Asia really look young for their age. So that could not really be the reason for feeling uncomfortable. Suddenly I understood why. It seemed to me that the boy was not really the master of his senses. He seemed to be overwhelmed by the situation he got into. Not able to offer proper resistance, following his own will. That’s the point, that’s were the discussion and the law should be based on. People should be able to make a proper personal decision. Using drugs (including alcohol, and also money can be a drug) to force people to do things they normally would not do is not decent. The criterion of 18+ for porn is far too simple and illogical. In medieval until 1800, children married at the age of 12 or 13. In The Netherlands it is strictly forbidden to sell kids under eighteen alcohols. The number of minors with a life threatening delirium is still increasing! Laws should have certain flexibility and appeal to the source of evil. I think that drugging a 25 year old boy to make porn is a major offence and should lead to severe punishment.
- In The Netherlands they changed the law for porn in 1985 to 16+, but in 2002 they changed it again, to 18+. Since 2010 also porn with animals. Porn with actors who look younger then 18 is also forbidden (even when there is proof that they are 18+).
- In Sweden pornography is legal and free from 15+.
- In the U.S. porn films have to pass an obscenity test (actually they all pass). In most states porn is 18+, in some 21+.
- In Japan it was till the end of the 90’s not allowed to show genitals on film. They have no problem with the combination of sex and violence, nor teenage sex.
You see that there are some differences in our world.
For me they could make porn free 16+, because it seems a bit silly that youngsters can fuck around, but are not allowed to see it on film. However any abuse of actors (of all ages) should be severely punished.
And for the forum: you are totally right to keep 18+. It prevents problems.